The Effectiveness of a Design Process Model for Graduation Projects | ||
| International Design Journal | ||
| Article 33, Volume 12, Issue 2 - Serial Number 44, March and April 2022, Pages 431-443 PDF (2.21 M) | ||
| Document Type: Original Article | ||
| DOI: 10.21608/idj.2022.223042 | ||
| Author | ||
| Samaa Ahmed Waheed | ||
| Metal Products and jewelry Department, Faculty of Applied Arts, Helwan University. | ||
| Abstract | ||
| The product design students’ graduation project is a harvest of their efforts, not only for the duration of their performance of the project, which usually takes two semesters and allocates a distinct aspect of credit hours and an appropriate time of implementation hours. Students will do their best to prove their eligibility to obtain the degree, in which the graduation project is an important cornerstone, despite it being at the end of their career. Research problem: It is not possible for all the courses taught by the design student to provide the full knowledge that enables him to solve problems that may not have appeared before and cannot cover the wide range covered by the field of product design in particular. This is why there should be an A design process model for graduation projects that enables them to bridge the knowledge and skill gap in a limited time. And that this model is designed for this purpose because of the wide range of different consumer needs and the clear diversity in the tools and skills required, in addition to the requirement for speed of completion due to the lack of time available. The current study proposes this model and also provides an objective comparison between a project implemented by students with and without the proposed model. The study notes that there is a clear gap between students about to graduate and experienced professional product designers. Therefore, the main question of this study was, is it possible to provide a model for a design process model to reduce this gap and compensate students during the project period for what they may have missed during their study years? Objective of the study: This study aimed to develop a model for the Design Process that provides the best ways to speed up bridging this gap, train students and enable them at their current level and the inexperienced experience they gained throughout the study period to reach knowledge of the product in question within a short period of time. It also aimed to compare the performance of students who practiced the graduation project using this model with others who did not use it. Research Methodology: The study uses both the descriptive survey and the descriptive analytical method, in addition to the inductive method, which provides the main tool in building the required model. Results: The study found a model for the design process that bridges the gap between the requirements for graduating a successful designer characterized by qualities, capabilities and knowledge that suit industrial and societal needs, and what the study provides in design education institutions. | ||
| Keywords | ||
| Graduation Project; Design Process Model; Assessment Rubrics | ||
| References | ||
|
[1] Final Year Graduation Project Handbook, (2012), College of Computer and Information Systems, Umm Al-Qura University, Mekkah, Saudi Arabia, January 2012.
[2] Ullman D., (2003) The Mechanical Design Process, Third Edition New York, .
[3] Frank D., (1999) The Importance of Knowledge Management for BMW, Keynote Address, ICED conference, Technical University of Munchen, Germany
[4] Ahmed S., K.M. Wallace, L. Blessing and M. Moss (2000) identifying differences between Novice and Experienced Designers, Design for Excellence, Proceedings of the Engineering Design Conference 2000, , Edited by S. Sivaloganathan and P.T.J. Andrews, Professional Engineering Publishing, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk, UK 2000 pp 97–106.
[5] Ahmed S, K.M. Wallace and L. Blessing, (2003) Understanding the Differences Between How Novice and Experienced Designers Approach Design Tasks, Research in Engineering Design Vol 14 2003 pp 1–11.
[6] Jones J.C.. (1966) Design Methods Reviewed, in The Design Method, Edited by Gregory S.A., Butterworths, London.
[7] Gregory S.A. and Monk J.D., (1972) Creativity: Definitions and Models, in Creativity and Innovation in Engineering, Edited by S.A. Gregory Butterworths.
[8] Pugh S., (1966) Creating Innovative Products Using Total Design, Edited by Don Clausing and Ron Andrade, Addison Wesley Publishing Company, Reading Massachusetts,.
[9] Thomas S., (2001) A Study of the Application of Structured Design Methodologies Employed in the Development of Ford Fusion, Dissertation for the Degree of MS c in Quality Management, Statistical Methods and Reliability, City University, London March 2001.
[10] Cross M., (2008) Developing Company-Specific Design Process Models’ PhD Thesis, Brunel University, London, England.
[11] Mohamed M.Adib Alnejem (2018), Developing of Evaluation Criterions for Graduation Projects in Interior Design Specialization -OCMT as A Case Study, Journal of University of Babylon, 2018, Volume 26, Issue 7, Pages 250-270
[12] Somaya Al-Aishawi (2012) Practicing the design process for developing creative thinking skills, International Design Journal, Volume 1, Issue 1 https://www.faa-design.com/files/1/1/1-1-wasmia.pdf
[13] Prof. Mohamed Ezzat Saad Mahmoud, Mufida Sadiq Al Akiyabi, Esra Osama Ali, Samar Farouk Abdel Qawi Hassan (2010) The dual diamond methodology shortens the design process time, International Design Journal, Volume 10, Issue 3 https://www.faa-design.com/files/10/37/211-222%2010-3-samar.pdf
[14] Fikri Jamal Ibrahim, Osama Youssef Mohamed, Ahmed Mohamed Zayed Ahmed (2018) to benefit from the theory of multiple intelligences in industrial design education, International Design Journal, Volume 8, No. 3 - 2018, pg. 307-315 https://www.faa-design.com/files/8/27/8-3-zayd.pdf
[15] Iman Hashem (2014) Requirements for the preparation of the industrial designer in the light of recent changes in the field of design, International Design Journal, Volume 4, Issue 4, Autumn 2014, pg. 87-94 https://www.faa-design.com/files/4/12/87%204-4-hashem.pdf
[16] Donia Beltayeb (2017) Teaching the design project in the “Interior Design Studio” Foundations and Concepts, International Design Journal, Volume 7, Issue 4
https://idj.journals.ekb.eg/article_89163_c8c265dedc096beeceacc4d5ffc8f33d.pdf1
[17] Muhammad Ezzat Saad (2010) The Philosophy of Designing Products of an Engineering Nature, Author Publisher
[18] Yasser Muhammad Al-Sadiq (2014) Visual Culture and its Relationship to Design Education, International Design Journal, Volume Five, Issue Four, pp. 1631-1643 https://idj.journals.ekb.eg/article_102342_3cdad98c758c56803bd1d8918e9ee2eb.pdf
[19] Salwa Youssef Abdel Bari and Sana Abdel Gawad Issa (2019) Develop a design methodology that supports innovation and creative abilities among design students, Source: Journal of Architecture, Arts and Humanities: Arab Association for Islamic Civilization and Arts No. 17 2019 pp. 233-251
[20] Haitham Muhammad Jalal Muhammad (2017) Intelligent Design and Its Support for the Philosophy of Design, Journal of Architecture, Arts and Humanities, Arab Society for Islamic Civilization and Arts Issue 7 July 2017, pp. 731-718 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/923795
[21] Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed Rahma and Omar Ahmed Al-Khalifa Makki (2016) The role of applications of principles and methods of creative thinking and problem solving in the development of the industrial product design process. Journal of Human Sciences, Sudan University of Science and Technology - College of Fine and Applied Arts, Volume 17, Issue 1, pp. 198-217 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/754915
[22] Salah Nouri Mahmoud, Shaima Muayyad Mustafa, (2021) Intellectual Style in Industrial Product Design, Journal of Middle East Research, Ain Shams University - Middle East Research Center, Issue 66 August 2021 pp. 460-444 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/1206934
[23] Waleed Muhammad Mahdi (2015) Technical variables and their implications for the industrial product design system, Journal of the College of Basic Education, Al-Mustansiriya University - College of Basic Education, No. 91, pages 661-692 https://iasj.net/iasj/article/114447
[24] Sami Abdel-Fattah Saleh Mustafa, Rehab Mahmoud Mohamed Kamel, Mohamed Naguib Mahmoud Abdel-Aal, George Wajih Aziz Badawy, (2009) The philosophy of group thinking and its role in developing the approach to designing presentation and production methods, a case study, Journal of Sciences and Arts - Studies and Research, Helwan University, Volume 21 Issue January 1, Pages 158 – 147 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/70476
[25] Khaled Mohamed Gad Said, (2005) The Industrial Environment and Its Relationship to the Design Strategy and Production of Metal Furniture, Journal of Science and Arts - Studies and Research, Helwan University, Volume 17, Issue 4, October, Pages: 149 – 135 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/69511
[26] Tariq Ismail Mohamed Abdel Latif ((2000b) Benefiting from the applications of simple construction in the field of industrial design, Journal of Sciences and Arts - Studies and Research, Helwan University Vol. 15 No. 3, July pp. 77-59 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/69238
[27] Tariq Ismail Mohamed Abdel Latif, (2000a) Devising a new method for computer design using the morphological approach in thinking, Journal of Science and Arts - Studies and Research, Helwan University, Vol. 12, No. 1, January pp. 28-1 http://search.mandumah. com/Record/68642
[28] Rajab Hilal Abdel-Gawad (1998) A critical and analytical study in the history of design methods and theories, Journal of Science and Arts - Studies and Research, Helwan University, Volume 10, Issue 4, October pp. 112-99 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/68496
[29] Ahmed Mohamed Omar Badawy, (1998) Product Analysis and Function Analysis in Metal Products Design, Journal of Science and Arts, Studies and Research, Helwan University, Volume 10, Issue 3, July 1998, pages: 76-63 http://search.mandumah.com/Record/68475
[30] Nawal Mohsen Ali and Barakat, Mustafa Mohamed. (2015) Integration in the industrial design system. Academic, University of Baghdad College of Fine Arts, Volume 2015, Issue 73, pp. 167-188 https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-694997
[31] College of Applied Technical Sciences, (2016) Graduation Project Preparation Guide, German Jordanian University, Jordan,
[32] Sabah Muhammad Abdul-Muhib, Muhammad Reda Shaker Chalabi, Laith Mashkour, Rashid Qandil (2009) A comparative study of the graduation projects of architecture in Iraq and Spain, Iraqi journal of mechanical and material engineering, 2009, Volume B, Special Issue first conf. / eng. coll., Pages 308-320
[33] Remke Klapwijk (2021) Creativity in Design, In: Clare Benson and Suzanne Lawson (editors), Teaching Design and Technology Creatively, Routledge,
[34] Sternberg, R. and Lubart T. (1999) 'The Concept of Creativity: Prospects and Paradigms'. Handbook of creativity. 1, 3-15. | ||
|
Statistics Article View: 2,655 PDF Download: 2,370 |
||
