VIBRATION ANALYSIS OF ADDING CONTAMINANTS PARTICLES AND CARBON NANOTUBES TO LITHIUM GREASE OF BALL BEARING

VIBRATION ANALYSIS OF ADDING CONTAMINANTS PARTICLES AND CARBON NANOTUBES TO LITHIUM GREASE OF BALL BEARING

Nabhan, A.

Production Engineering and Mechanical Design Department, Faculty of Engineering,

Minia University, Egypt.

E-mail: a.nabhan@mu.edu.eg.

ABSTRACT

This paper examines vibration behavior of ball bearings dispersed by solid as a function of contamination of lubricant. Experimental tests were performed using SKF 6004 deep groove ball bearing, dispersed with different contaminants particles. Silica sandwith different particle sizes, copper (Cu micro particles), poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA), low-density polyethylene (LDPE), and polyamide (PA), all at five concentration levels were used to disperse the lubricant. The contaminants concentration as well as the carbon nanotubes (CNT_s) concentration is varied as 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 wt. %. It was found that as the contaminants particles size and concentration increased, the corresponding acceleration values also increased up to certain limit. Furthermore, the vibration amplitudes decrease due to the increase of the copper concentration. The vibration amplitude was improved due to increase of concentration of carbon nanotubes CNTs.

KEYWORDS

Ball bearing, vibration,carbon nanotubes, solidcontaminants.

INTRODUCTION

Antifriction bearings are the most critical parts in rotating machinery. Main function of these bearings depends on the smooth and quiet running of the roller elements. The behavior of the roller elements have a significant effect on bearing performance. Solid contaminants are denting of the bearing raceways and roller elements. Solid contaminants may be the cause of bearing failure. Therefore the dynamic behavior of antifriction bearing may be monitored using vibration measurements and wear debris analysis, [1-2].

Influence of contaminants in the grease of the rolling bearing was investigated using the acoustic emission, [3]. It was found that,small size contaminant particles generated a higher acoustic emission pulse count level than large size particles. The behavior of lubricant contamination by solid Particles on the vibration signals of roller bearings was investigated. The experimental tests were performed with applied radial Load was 10% of the bearing nominal load. The roller bearings NU 205 were used, which lubricated with mineral oil of different viscosity grades, [4 - 5]. Quartz powder in three concentration levels and different particle sizes was used to contaminate the oil, [6 - 7]. The dolomite powder in three concentration levels and different particle sizes was used to contaminate the grease with deep groove ball bearings, [8]. Different materials such as Silica, metal-burr, dolomite-powder, iron-ore, and sawdust, all at three concentration levels and different particle sizes were used to contaminate the lubricant, [9 - 10].

Al₂O₃ nanoparticles as lubricating oil additives were investigated, and it is showed that the friction coefficient was decreased by 40–50% in comparison with the solution without Al₂O₃ particles, [11-12]. Modified SiO₂ nanoparticles as lubricating oil additives had better tribological properties in terms of load-carrying capacity, anti-wear and friction reduction, [13 - 14]. Al₂O₃/SiO₂ composite nanoparticles were expected to be more interesting when they were used as lubricating oil additives [15-18].Modified Al₂O₃/SiO₂ composite nanoparticles as lubricating oil additives were investigated by four-ball and thrust-ring tests in terms of vibration and coefficient of friction. It is found that their anti-wear and anti-friction performances are better than those of pure Al₂O₃ or SiO₂ nanoparticles, [19].The vibration characteristics of ball bearing supplied with nano-copper oxide (CuO) mixed lubricant was investigated. The results show a reduce of 41% vibration amplitude while using 0.2% (W/V) CuO nanoparticles in outer case defected compared to pure lubricant, [20].

The objective of this work is to investigate vibration behavior when ball bearings are dispersed by solid contaminates. Experimental tests were performed in SKF 6004 deep groove ball bearing, contaminated with different contaminants particles. The effect of carbon nanotubes CNT_s as lubricant additives was investigated. The contaminants concentration as well as the carbon nanotubes CNT_s concentration is varied as 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 wt. % of the solid lubricant.

EXPERIMENTAL

Materials and Methods

The bearing type that has be used in this study is a single row deep groove ball bearing SKF 6004. Lithium grease without additive was used as a basic lubricant. Generally, different materials such as silica sandof (0 - 150 μm) "A", (150 - 300 μm) "B", (300 - 600 μm) "C", and (600 - 1400 μm) "D" particle sizes, copper (Cu microparticles), low density polyethylene (LDPE), polymethyl methacrylate(PMMA), and polyamide (PA), all at five concentration levels were used to disperse the grease. The morphology of the used contaminants particles is shown in Fig. 1.

Fig. 1 The morphology of the contaminants particles.

Carbon nanotubes CNT_s were of the size range outside diameter: >50 nm, inside diameter: 5-15 nm, and length: 5-20 um. Carbon nanotubes CNT_s were added to the lubricant. The contaminants concentration as well as the carbon nanotubes CNT_s concentration is varied as 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 wt. % of the lithium grease.

An experimental setup is employed in this workwith the purpose of obtaining the vibration response related to different testing conditions of the bearing element contact. Fig. 2 schematically shows the tested ball bearing in the rig. An optical encoder is used for the speed measurement. An elastic claw coupling is utilized to damp out the high-frequency vibration generated by the motor. Two ball bearings are fitted into the solid housings. Accelerometers (IMI Sensors- 603C01) are mounted on the housing of the tested bearing to measure the vibration signals along two directions. Vibration signatures are analyzed in terms acceleration values at particular defect frequencies and also in terms of overall root mean square (RMS) values.

Vibration was determined through the processing and analysis of bearing radial vibration data, obtained from each of the lubrication conditions, during 1.5 hr. of test run for temperature stabilization and under several bearing shaft speeds. The applied radial load was 20 % of the bearing basic load. Through root mean square (RMS) analysis of the vibration signals, it was possible to identify specific frequency bands modulated by the change in contaminants concentration and the Carbon nanotubes CNT_s concentration.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

3.1 Analysis of contaminant particles adding

The experimental results were carried out in two groups. The first group is depending on adding different particles size of the silica with different concentrations. The added silica have particles size of (0 - 150 μm) "A", (150 - 300 μm) "B", (300 - 600 μm) "C", and (600 - 1400 μm) "D", as shown in Fig. 1. Figure 3 illustrates the variation of RMS amplitude of the acceleration for ball bearing with concentration of added silica. It shows that when the additive concentration of particles is increased, the RMS amplitude increases. The variation of RMS values may be due to the interaction of silica particles on the contact area between the balls and the races of the bearing, as shown in Fig. 4. The lubricant specimens after the test were analyzed. Images of cutting particles found in the lubricant samples from silica"A" were shown in Fig. 5. It was observed that the silica "A", particles size of (0 - 150 μm), has greater effect on the increase of the wear rate. It can be concluded that the RMS give high results with increase of the concentration of silica through disturbing and breaking the grease film inside the bearing. Moreover the wear rate increased with the decrease of silica particles size. The second group is tested with adding copper (Cu micro particles), poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA), low-density polyethylene (LDPE), and polyamide (PA) to solid lubricant.The variation of RMS amplitude of the acceleration for ball bearing with concentration of added silica is shown in Fig. 6.  It is observed that the increase of the RMS amplitude due to increase of the concentration of the polymeric additives. Also, it is noticed that poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA) gives higher values of RMS acceleration amplitude. Furthermore, the RMS amplitude values decreased when the concentration of the copper particles increased.

Fig. 3 RMS acceleration amplitude versus contaminants concentration for group A.

Fig.4 A sketch of contaminants interaction in contact area of bearing.

Fig. 5 The morphology of lubricant specimen of silica A.

Fig. 6 RMS acceleration amplitude versus contaminants concentration for group B.

3.2 Analysis of carbon nanotubes CNT_s adding

Figure 6 illustrates the variation of RMS amplitude of the acceleration for ball bearing with time. In the experiment, the RMS amplitudes were measured every second. The RMS amplitude averaged from every 15 min. original data were displayed in Fig. 7. It is important to notice that the RMS amplitudes of lubricant with carbon nanotubes CNT_s are all smaller than that of pure lubricating grease. It can be concluded that the vibration performance was improved due to increase of concentration of carbon nanotubes CNT_s.

Fig. 7 Experimental variation of the acceleration RMS with time.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present work, the effect of solid contaminants in grease on vibration response of ball bearing was studied. For bearing with contaminant free grease, all the frequencies are at minimum level. As the contaminants particles size and concentration are increased, the corresponding acceleration values also increase up to certain limit. Furthermore, the vibration amplitudes decrease due to increase of the copper concentration.

With smaller particle size and varying concentration level of silica, the wear rate gives the highest results. This may be attributed to the fact that particles may come in direct contact with rotating elements, break the grease film separating the contacting elements of the bearing.

Due to carbon nanotubes CNT_s, which was 0.5 wt. %, introduced in lithium grease, the vibration amplitudes of bearings is reduced by 32 %.

REFERENCES

1. Roylance B. J., Hunt T. M., "Wear Debris Analysis", Coxmoor Publishing Company, Oxford, UK, (1999). 

2. T. Braron, "Engineering Condition Mointoring", Addison Wesley longman, (1996).  

3. Miettinen J., Andersson P., "Acoustic emission of rolling bearings lubricated with contaminated grease", Tribology International, Vol. 33, pp. 777 – 787, (2000).

4. Serrato R., Maru M.M.,  Padovese L.R., "Effect of lubricant oil viscosity and contamination on the Mechanical signature of roller bearing", 12^th International Conference on Sound and Vibration, Vol. 87, pp. 514-567, (2005).

5. Serrato R., Maru M.M.,  Padovese L.R., "Effect of lubricant viscosity grade on mechanical vibration of roller bearings", Tribology International, Vol. 40, pp. 1270-1275, (2007).

6. Maru M.M., Castillo R.S., Padovese L.R., "Study of solid contamination in ball Bearings through vibration and wear analyses", Tribology International, Vol. 40, pp. 433–44, (2006).

7. Serrato R., Maru M.M., Padovese L.R.,"Effect of the Presence of Solid Contamination and the Resulting Wear on the Mechanical Signature of Ball Bearings", 18^th International Congress of Mechanical Engineering, Ouro Preto, MG, (2005).

8. Mahajan O.L., Utpat A.A., “Study of Effect of Solid Contaminants in the Lubricant on Ball Bearings Vibration", International Journal of Instrumentation, Control and Automation (IJICA), Vol. 1, (2012).

9. More Y.Y., Deshmukh A.P., "Study of Effect of Solid Contaminants in Grease on Performance of Ball Bearing by Vibrationan Analysis", International Journal of Innovations in Engineering Research and Technology [IJIERT], Vol. 2, Issue 5, (2015).

10. Godase S.P., Nehe S.S., Anatharama B., "Analysis of Effect of Solid Contaminants in Lubrication on vibration response of Ball bearing", International Engineering Research Journal (IERJ), Vol. 1, Issue 7, pp. 545-549, (2015).

11. Radice S., Mischler S., "Effect of electrochemical and mechanical parameters on the lubrication behaviour of Al₂O₃ nanoparticles in aqueous suspensions", Wear, Vol. 261, pp.1032–1041, (2006).

12. Shi G., Zhang M.Q., Rong M.Z., Bernd W., Klaus F., "Sliding wear behavior of epoxy containing nano-. Al₂O₃ particles with different pretreatments", Wear, Vol. 256, pp. 1072–1081, (2004).

13. X.H. Li, Z. Cao, Z.J. Zhang, H.X. Dang, "Surface-modification in situ of nano- SiO₂ and its structure and tribological properties", Appl. Surf. Sci., Vol. 252, pp. 7856–7861, (2006).

14. Peng D.X., Kang Y., Hwang R.M., Shyr S.S., Chang Y.P., "Tribological properties of diamond and SiO₂ nanoparticles added in paraffin", Tribology International, Vol. 42,  pp. 911–917, (2009).

15. Ma S.Y., Zheng S.H., Ding H.Y., Li W., "Anti-wear and reduce-friction ability of ZrO₂/SiO₂ self-lubricating composites", Adv. Mater. Res., 79–82, pp.  1863–1866, (2009).

16. Li W., Zheng S.H., Ma S.Y., Ding H.Y., Jiao D., Cao B.Q., "Study of surface modification of ZrO₂/SiO₂ nano composites with aluminum zirconium coupling agent", Asian J. Chem. Vol. 23, pp. 705–708, (2011).

17. Gu C.X., Li Q.Z., Gu Z.M., Zhu G.Y., "Study on application of CeO₂ and CaCO₃ nanoparticles in lubricating oils", Journal of Rare Earth, Vol. 26, pp.163–167, (2008).

18. Mangam V., Bhattacharya S., Das K., Das S., "Friction and wear behavior of Cu–CeO₂ nano composite coatings synthesized by pulsed electrode position", Surf. Coat. Technol., Vol. 205, pp. 801–805, (2010).

19. Jiao D., et al., "The tribology properties of alumina/silica composite nanoparticles as lubricant additives", Applied Surface Science, Vol. 257, pp. 5720–5725, (2011).

20. Prakash E., Kumar S., Kumar M., "Experimental studies on vibration characteristics on ball bearing operated with copper oxide nano particle mixed lubricant", International Journal of Engineering and Technology, Vol. 5, pp. 957- 1175. (2013).