THE ICONOGRAPHY OF DEPICTING NAKED ENEMIES IN ANCIENT EGYPT AND MESOPOTAMIA: A COMPARATIVE STUDY | ||
| Journal of the General Union of Arab Archaeologists | ||
| Article 1, Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024, Pages 1-19 PDF (3.39 M) | ||
| Document Type: Original Article | ||
| DOI: 10.21608/jguaa2.2023.179468.1120 | ||
| Author | ||
| Fawziah Abdulghani* | ||
| Professor of Archaeology of Ancient Near East, Faculty of Archaeology/ Cairo University, Egypt. | ||
| Abstract | ||
| دلالات تصوير الأسرى العراة في مصر القديمة وبلاد العراق القديم [دراسة مقارنة] [AR] تهدف هذه الدراسة إلى مناقشة دلالات تصوير الأعداء العراة في كل من مصر القديمة والعراق القديم. وتقتصر على تمثيل الأعداء العراة من الرجال فقط دون الأطفال أو النساء. ويكمن السبب في اختيار هذا الموضوع إلى إلقاء المزيد من الضوء على أوجه الشبه والاختلاف بين تمثيل الأسرى العراة، وكذلك المقارنة بين مفهوم تجريدهم من ملابسهم في مناظر كلتا الحضارتين. وقد ناقشت الدراسة أهم هذه التمثيلات واستعرضتها للإجابة على كثير من الأسئلة التي تدور حول هذا الموضوع ، ومنها: ما الحضارة التي ظهر هذا النمط في مناظرها أكثر من الأخرى هل هي مصر القديمة أم العراق القديم؟ وهل العري مرتبط بمفهوم عقوبة الأسرى أو العصاة بشكل عام؟ وإلى أي مدى يرتبط العري بمفهوم العار أو الخزي والمهانة بشكل عام وبخاصة للعدو المهزوم؟ وما مدى ارتباط العري بفكرة الموت؟ وهل اقتصر تمثيل الأسرى وقد جردوا من ملابسهم في مناظر مصر القديمة والعراق القديم على الأعداء الأحياء فقط، أم على الأموات منهم، أم كلاهما الأعداء الأحياء والأموات؟ وقد استنتجت هذه الدراسة أن مناظر الأسرى العراة من الأعداء قد مثلت في العراق القديم أكثر منها في مصر القديمة، كما أن العري قد ارتبط بمفهوم العقاب لتعميق إحساس الخزي والعار وامتهان الأعداء. ولم يقتصر تمثيل الأسرى العراة الأموات دون الأحياء، بل مُثّل كلاهما عراة ، وإن زادت أمثلة مناظر الأسرى الموتى العراة أو المحكوم عليهم بالموت، حيث اقترن تمثيل الأسرى العراة الموتى مع الإعدام بطرق عديدة غاية في القسوة، كالسلخ والوضع على الخازوق، وبخاصة في مناظر العراق القديم في العصر الآشوري الحديث. [En]This study focuses on the iconography of depicting naked enemies in the ancient Egyptian and Iraqi civilizations. It is limited to the representation of naked, male enemies only, not women or children. The reason for choosing this topic is to shed more light on the similarities and differences in depicting scenes of naked captives and the concept of stripping prisoners of their clothes in both civilizations. This study also discusses and reviews the most important representations to answer many questions. For instance, which civilization portrays this motif more than ancient Egypt or Mesopotamia? Is nudity associated with the punishment of enemies, captives, prisoners, or the disobedient in general? To what extent is nudity generally related to the concept of shame concerning the defeated one or the enemy? To what extent is nudity related to the notion of death? Is stripping prisoners of their clothes in scenes from ancient Egypt and Iraq restricted to living enemies, the dead among them, or both? The study concludes that scenes of naked enemies in Mesopotamia occur more frequently than in ancient Egypt and that nudity is linked to the concept of punishment to deepen the sense of shame, disgrace, and humiliation of enemies. Moreover, the representation of nakedness includes dead and living enemies in both civilizations. However, depictions of dead, naked captives are also combined with cruel methods of execution, such as skinning and impalement, especially in Neo-Assyrian scenes. | ||
| Keywords | ||
| Ancient Egypt; Mesopotamia; captives; enemy; nakedness; nudity; prisoners | ||
| References | ||
|
Abdulghani, F.A.M.: «NãmãtÃlbãtãlÃlmūșãric ”sãyid ﹸlḥywãnã” fy finūn ﹸḫtãm ﹸlšãrq ﹸlﹸdnãﹸlqãdim hãtã nihãyãt ﹸlﹸlf ﹸlţãny qabl ﹸlmylãd, dirãșh mūqãrnãh», Journal of African Studies 45, 2019, 9-45.
Abdulghani, F.A.M.: «Representations of Homeless Children in Warlike Scenes in the Neo-Assyrian period», EJARS 10/1, 2020, 43-57.
Abdullah, M.: «The Foreign Captives in Ancient Egypt», PhD Thesis, Egyptology Department, Faculty of Archaeology, Cairo University, 2000.
Albenda, P.: «An Assyrian Relief Depicting a Nude Captive in Wellesley College», JNES 29/3, 1970, 145- 50.
Almekhlafy, A.A.E.: «Dirasah Leasbab Ekhtelaf Alckopat Alašoryah Alokhra wa acwanhom monzo alqarn althaleth cašar hatta alqarn alsabec qabl almylad»=«A study of the Difference in the Assyrian Punishments Against the Leaders of other Peoples and their Collaborators since the thirteenth century BC. until the Seventh BC», Historical Studies Journal 99/100, Damascus )University Press( 2007, 81-124.
Asher-Greve, J.M., & Sweeney, D.: «On Nakedness, Nudity, and Gender in Egyptian and Mesopotamian Art». In Images and Gender: Contributions to the Hermeneutics of Reading Ancient Art, Silvia Schroer (ed.), Orbis Bibilicus et Orientalis 220, Fribourg, 2006, 111 –62.
Assante, J.: «Undressing the Nude: Problems in Analyzing Nudity in Ancient Art, with an Old Babylonian Case Study». In Images and Gender: Contributions to the Hermeneutics of Reading Ancient Art, Silvia Schroer(ed.), Orbis Bibilicus et Orientalis 220, Fribourg, 2006, 177-207.
Bahrani, Z.: «The Iconography of the Nude in Mesopotamia», Notes in the History of Art 12/2, Essays on Nudity In Antiquity In Memory of Otto Brendel, 1993, 12-19.
David, A.: «Devouring the Enemy: Ancient Egyptian Metaphors of Domination», BACE 22, 2011, 83-100.
Duell, P.: The Mastaba of Mereruka I, Oriental Institute Publications 31, Chicago )The University of Chicago Oriental Institute Publication( 1938.
El-Nadi, M.: «Some Remarks on the Execution Place ḫbt in Ancient Egypt», JGUAA2 8/1, 2023, 26-43.
Erman, A., & H. Grapow, )eds.(: Wörterbuch der Ägyptischen Sprache, vol.3, Leipzig (J. Hinrichs) 1971.
Fazzini, R.A, Bianchi, R.S Romano, J.F., & Spanel, D.B.: Ancient Egyptian Art in the Brooklyn Museum, New York) The Brooklyn Muesum Publisher( 1989.
Gelb, I.J.: «Prisoners of War in Early Mesopotamia», JNES 32/1-2, 1973, 70-98.
Girit, A.: «Male Nudity in Ancient Mesopotamian Art», MA Thesis, Ihsan Dogramaci, Department of Archaeology /Bilkent University, Ankara, 2012.
Goelet, O.: «Nudity in Ancient Egypt», Notes in the History of Art1 2/2:Essays on Nudity in Antiquity in Memory of Otto Brendel, 1993, 20-31.
Hsu, S.: «Captured, Defeated, Tied and Fallen, Images of Enemies in Ancient Egypt», GM 252, 2017, 71-87.
Matić, U.: Body and Frames of War in New Kingdom Egypt: Violent Treatment of Enemies and Prisoners, Philippika - Altertumskundliche Abhandlungen134, Wiesbaden (Harrassowitz Verlag( 2019.
Nadali, D.: «Ashurbanipal against Elam, Figurative Patterns, and Architectural Location of the Elamite Wars», Historiae 4, 2007a, 57-91.
Nadali, D.: «Monuments of War, War of Monuments: Some Considerations on Commemorating War in the Third Millennium BC», Orientalia 76/ 4, 2007b, 336- 367.
Nadali, D.: «Sieges and Similes of Sieges in the Royal Annals: The Conquest of Damascus by Tiglath-Pileser III», KASKAL 6, 2009, 137-49.
Nadali, D.: Assyrian Open Field Battles: An Attempt at Reconstruction and Analysis, In Studies on War in the Ancient Near East. Collected Essays on Military History, J. Vidal )ed.), AOAT 372, Münster( Ugarit-Verlag) 2010, 117-152.
Nadali, D.: The Impact of War on Civilians in the Neo-Assyrian Period, Jordi Vidal & David Nadali (eds.), AOAT 413, Münster (Ugarit-Verlag) 2014, 101-111.
Nowicki, S.: «Enemies and Witches in the Scribal Tradition of Ancient Mesopotamia», Marginalized groups in Antiquity, Studien Zur Geschichtsforschung des Altertums 44, 2021, 11-33.
Orthmann, W.( ed.): Der Alte Orient, PKG, Band 14, Berlin )Propyläen Verlag( 1975.
Radner, K.: «High Visibility Punishment and Deterrent: Impalement in Assyrian Warfare and Legal Practice», in: Zeitschrift für Altorientalische und Biblische Rechtsgeschichte 21, Wiesbaden, 2015, 103- 128.
Radwan, A.: «ﹸlḫūtūt ﹸlc ãmãh licūșūr mãqãbl ﹸltãriḫ fy mișr», Cairo (Dãr Ãlhryry( 2004.
Robberger, E.: «The Nude at the Entrance. Contextualizing Male and Female Nudity in Early Mesopotamia Art», In Gender and Methodology in the Ancient Near East: Approaches from Assyriology and Beyond, S. L. Budin, M. Cifarelli, A. Garcia-Ventura, & A. Millet Albà(eds.), BMO 10, New York, New Jersey & Barcelona, 2018, 223-40.
Shaheen, A.E.A.: «Ãlrmzyãh Ãltãryḫyãh lilﹸqwãs ﹸltiscãh fy ﹸlmșãdir ﹸlmșryãh htty nhãyt ﹸldwlh ﹸlhdyṯh» = Journal of Historian 8, History Department, Faculty of Art, Cairo University, 1992, 35-64.
Winter, I.J.: «After the Battle is Over: The ‘Stele of the Vultures’ and the Beginning of Historical Narrative in the Ancient Near East», In Pictorial Narrative in Antiquity to the Middle Ages, H. Kessler & M. S. Simpson (eds.), Studies in the History of Art 16, Washington, 1985, 11-32.
Winter, I.J.: «On the Art in the Ancient Near East of the First Millennium BC”, in Culture and History of the Ancient Near East 34/1, Weippert, M.N.E.(ed.), Leiden, Boston, 2010.
Zara, M.: Glossary of Akkadian-Assyrian Words Still Used in Qaraqosh Dialect, Erbil-Iraq(Nuhran Press) 2020. | ||
|
Statistics Article View: 876 PDF Download: 637 |
||
